Silly question? Not really. The definition most dictionaries list first is that herbs are plants with no woody structure. Whether annual or perennial, they die to the ground either after flowering or at the end of each growing season. By this definition, banana trees are herbs and rosemary bushes are not.
The second, more familiar definition is that herbs are plants that are useful: as seasonings, as medicines, or for other practical purposes such as dying cloth. This covers an awful lot of ground and has its own problems — vegetables, for instance, which were included in the old herbals but are seldom thought of as herbs these days.
The bottom line seems to be that herbs are a lot like pornography: you may not be able to define it, but you know it when you see it.
Herbs for Shade
Most culinary herbs need lots of sunshine, but there are a few that should do all right with morning light, assuming the soil is well drained. Parsley, chervil, fennel, tarragon, lemon balm, sweet cicely, sweet woodruff, and any of the mints will grow in shade.
Hardy Herb Garden
It’s so lovely to plant herbs that will survive winter and reliably come back year after year. There are many hardy herbs that fit that bill. A hardy culinary herb garden might include chives, garlic chives, fennel, sage, tarragon, thymes, winter savory, oregano, and mint (remember to keep the mint roots contained).
A hardy medicinal herb garden might include arnica, catnip, echinacea, feverfew, valerian, and comfrey.
And some annual herbs are such rampant self-sowers that you may only have to plant them once. Borage, dill, chervil, and coriander will come back year after year as long as you let the plants go to seed. They won’t necessarily come up right where you want them, but a little untidiness never hurt anybody!
Choose your Thyme wisely
In my garden, I’ve planted creeping thyme between stepping stones for the lovely appearance. How does this differ from the thyme I have planted in my herb garden you might ask. Creeping thyme, Thymus praecox, is edible but less aromatic and flavorful that the equally low-growing wild thyme, aka mother-of-thyme (Thymus pulegioides), which is both edible and tasty. In either cased, however, plants you’ve been walking on are not generally good candidates for slipping into the stew.
Curly vs Flat Parsley
Standing in front of the display at the garden center, the question is: which parsley do you choose for your garden this year? Think of curly parsley, Petroselinum crispum, and flat-leaf (or Italian) parsley, P. crispum var. neapolitanum, as fraternal twins. They aren’t identical, but botanically they are very close, and they have the same growing needs. The difference comes later: in the kitchen, where flat-leaf tends to have a stronger flavor (and be much easier to wash); and in the small, tight bouquets called tussie-mussies, where the curly variety is a more decorative choice. Don’t make the mistake of buying large plants and then trying to transplant them. The roots are easily damaged, and if they are, the plant will quickly bolt to seed instead of making lots of tasty foliage.
Note: parsley and thyme will stay usable well into cold weather. Try not to touch the leaves if they’re frozen or they’ll go limp. Let them thaw naturally or throw them into your stew pot.
Culinary Sage
Sage leaves taste best when they are young. Tender and delicate in early spring, they get tougher and more aromatic as the weather warms. Flavor is at its complex peak when flowers are just starting to form, and that is the best time to harvest a crop for drying.
To get the tastiest fresh sage, cut early and often, forcing the plant to make lots of new growth. The essential oils that give young leaves their lemony quality are volatile. As they dissipate, the leaves taste more and more like dried sage, a combination of camphor and pine. That sounds like a flavor too tough to kill, but it too fades over time.
The Old Country Look vs Reality
You’ve seen the pictures a million times: bunches of dried herbs hanging from the beams in a country kitchen, a beautifully arranged wreath of dried herbs and flowers (or bright red chiles) within snipping distance of the stove. It looks easy and practical, as well as cozy and homelike.
But it’s not really a good idea — unless you plan to use up the goodies in a very short time. Dried foods left exposed in a working kitchen will be magnets for grease and/or dust, and their quality will be degraded by light, heat, and steam. The old-time farmers whose kitchens inspired this look had airier kitchens (no insulation) and lower expectations about cleanliness of their food.
Once harvested, fresh herbs keep best when loosely wrapped in damp toweling and stored in the refrigerator. Unfortunately, out of sight is all too often out of mind — and off the menu. To avoid forgotten-herb syndrome, pick a small bunch every week and keep it in a vase of water on the kitchen counter. Even though you know they’re as close as the fridge (or a walk to the garden), you’ll find yourself using a lot more of everything from parsley and basil to lovage and chervil when there is a beautiful green bouquet of them right in front of you while you cook.
Enjoy our previous post on harvesting and drying your herbs: